What to Know About Insurance Roof Replacement After a Storm

Severe weather can strike at any time—bringing wind, hail, or heavy rain that may compromise one of your home’s most important defenses: the roof. Whether you’ve just been through a storm or are preparing for future risks, it’s important to understand what roof damage looks like, how insurance roof replacement works under your specific policy, and what steps to take if your home is affected.

Read on to discover four steps you can take to determine if roof damage needs to be addressed to prevent further deterioration and maintain the value of your home.

Step 1: Start With a Visual Inspection

After a storm passes, one of the first things you should do is safely inspect your property for visible damage. Here are some factors to look for:

• Missing shingles or obvious impact points on the roof, as well as any roofing components that have fallen to the ground
• Dents or cracks on your windows, garage doors, or outdoor air conditioning unit
• Damage to fencing, outdoor buildings, or play structures
• Water stains or discoloration on ceilings or walls, indicating possible leaks
• Holes in vinyl siding, dents in aluminum siding, or impact marks to other siding materials

Remember that hail damage isn’t always easy to spot from the ground, especially if the damage is to just your roof.

Learn More: Addressing Hail Damage: What You Need to Know

Step 2: Connect With Your Insurance Agent

If you suspect your roof may be damaged, reach out to your insurance agent to discuss your options. They can help you determine whether filing a claim makes sense based on:

• The extent of the damage
• Your deductible
• Whether other claims have been reported in your area

In some cases, your agent may suggest bringing in a trusted roofing contractor to assess the condition of your roof before filing a claim. In others—particularly during significant, widespread weather events—they may recommend moving forward with the claims process right away.

Get insights like this right in your inbox. Subscribe to the Central Blog below.

Step 3: Understand the Claims Process

Once you file a claim, your insurance carrier will assign a claims adjuster. Their role is to evaluate the damage and determine if the roof damage is caused by a covered peril under your insurance policy. If the roof damage is covered under the policy, the adjuster will assess the scope of the damage to estimate if repair or full replacement of the roof is warranted and the cost.

Remember: Every policyholder is not entitled to a whole new roof after roof damage occurs, unless the covered damages outlined in their policy warrant a full replacement. For example, you may only be entitled to a repair of a section of the roof or the replacement of only one slope.

The repair or replacement needs may vary depending on the extent of damage and the type of roofing material you have, such as:

• Three-tab shingles (typically rated for 20 years)
• Dimensional shingles (rated for 30+ years)
• Other roofing materials like metal, tile, or wood shakes
• Roof design, style, and pitch

The adjuster will also flag any potential problem areas that could lead to leaks or future issues. Understanding these findings can help you make informed decisions about next steps and long-term protection.

Step 4: Choose a Trusted Roofing Contractor

If a roof repair or replacement is necessary, it’s essential to choose your contractor carefully. Unfortunately, storm damage can bring out opportunistic scammers. Look for these red flags:

• High-pressure sales tactics or unsolicited door-to-door offers
• Requests for large upfront payments
• Excessive interest in your insurance policy details
• Claims of new roofs with no out-of-pocket cost to you

To find a reputable roofer:

• Ask your independent insurance agent
• Ask friends or neighbors for referrals
• Check references, reviews, and ratings from the Better Business Bureau
• Verify warranties on both materials and workmanship

Some contractors may also recommend upgraded materials or enhanced ventilation systems that could improve your roof’s longevity and your home’s energy efficiency. While these suggestions may be a good idea and something to consider, remember that, typically, your insurance policy would not cover these additions.

Remember: If you’re ever nervous about the validity of a contractor or their recommendations, consider reaching out to your carrier for a business check. Top carriers like Central have fraud mitigation teams equipped to confirm the good standing of contractors in your area. You can learn more about Central’s industry-leading fraud detection team here.

The Central Difference: Trusted Guidance When You Need It Most

When it comes to something as important as your roof, having the right insurance partner matters.

At Central, we’re here to guide, protect, and advocate for you every step of the way. Our experienced agents and adjusters work closely with you to ensure you understand your options, from evaluating potential damage to selecting trusted contractors.

We also offer an added layer of protection through our industry-leading Special Investigations Unit (SIU). Our fraud team is nationally recognized for its proactive approach to identifying and stopping roofing scams. If you’re ever unsure about a contractor’s intentions—or find yourself in a difficult situation—our team is ready to step in, investigate, and help protect you from further harm.

Paired with tools like aerial imagery from the Geospatial Insurance Consortium and a personalized underwriting approach, Central delivers more than a policy—we deliver peace of mind. When you work with Central, you’re backed by a team that’s dedicated to guiding you through the claims process, promptly addressing your concerns, and delivering timely solutions based on the terms of your policy.

If you’re reviewing your coverage or facing a potential insurance roof replacement, talk to your independent Central agent. We’re here to protect what matters most.